Your child holds up a drawing. It's a brown smudge with legs, possibly a dog, possibly a cloud. "Good job," you say, already looking back at the pan on the hob. They look at the drawing, then at you, then wander off. Something didn't land, and neither of you quite knows what.

"Good job" is what comes out when we're busy and we love them. There's nothing wrong with it. But it's a bit like a pat on the head: kind, quick, and gone. Children often want something more. They want to know that we actually looked.

Why "good job" can fall flat

At 3 to 5, children show you things constantly. A jump off the step. A puddle splash. A picture. What they're really asking is "Did you see me?" A quick "well done" answers a slightly different question.

At 6 to 10, children start to notice when praise is automatic, and some begin to distrust it. Others get hooked on it, checking your face after every sentence they write. Praise that's all about being clever or brilliant can make a child nervous of trying anything they might not be clever or brilliant at. If being good at things is what earns your warmth, failing starts to feel risky.

Describe what you see

The simplest shift is from judging to noticing. Instead of "good job", say what you actually see. "You used so much brown. Is that a dog? Look at his tail going." "You jumped off the second step this time." "You kept going even when the zip got stuck."

Describing tells a child that you were really there. It leaves the judgement to them, which is where we want it to grow. Often you'll find they fill the silence themselves. "And he's got a ball," they'll say, and you're suddenly in a conversation rather than handing out a grade.

When you do praise, lean on effort, choices and care, not talent. "You tried three different ways" is more useful than "you're so clever", because effort is something a child can do again tomorrow. The playbook on effort and practice goes further into this.

As for rewards, a sticker chart can be handy for one stubborn task, like a new toothbrushing habit. But used for things a child might enjoy anyway, rewards can quietly take the joy out. Reading for stickers can turn reading into a job. The guide on perfectionism in children explores what happens when children start doing things only for the tick.

At a glanceNoticing instead of judging
  1. Really lookPause and take in what they're showing you. Being properly seen is what most children are asking for.
  2. Describe itSay what you notice: the colours, the tries, the care. Leave the judging to them.
  3. Name the effortPraise trying, choosing and keeping going, because those are things a child can do again tomorrow.
  4. Go easy on rewardsKeep stickers for dull jobs, not for things they might enjoy for their own sake.
Sun Sparkle, from the Wundoria stories

Sun Sparkle, the smiling sunIn the stories, Sun Sparkle shows that a child's brightness is always there, even on cloudy days, already shining and waiting to be remembered. Meet Sun Sparkle

Noticing out in the world

Outside is a lovely place to practise this, because there's so much to describe and nobody is marking anything. On a walk, try narrating what your child does, gently, like a nature programme. "She's found a stick. She's testing whether it bends. It does."

Children usually find this hilarious, and secretly delightful. It's the feeling of being watched kindly. You can also turn it round and let them narrate you. You'll learn a great deal about what they notice, and about what you look like trying to climb over a stile.

What you'll need

  • A pause to really look at what they show you
  • A walk to narrate like a nature programme
  • A few describing words in your pocket
  • Stickers kept for dull jobs only

Our tips

  1. Swap "good job" for what you actually see: the colours, the tries, the care.
  2. Praise trying and choosing, because they can do those again tomorrow.
  3. Ask "how do you feel about it?" and let them be the judge.

For the fridge: one small step a day

  • MonDescribe one drawing instead of judging it
  • TueNarrate their walk like a nature show
  • WedName one effort: "You kept going"
  • ThuLet them narrate you outdoors
  • FriAsk: "Tell me about this bit"
  • SatNotice a kind moment out loud
  • SunAsk: which part are you most pleased with?
One small thing each day, the same gentle rhythm the Wundoria app uses for its daily doors.

Words to try

  • "Tell me about this bit."
  • "You worked really hard on that."
  • "You didn't give up when it got tricky."
  • "How do you feel about it?"
  • "That was kind. Did you see her face?"

Try asking (afterwards): "Which part are you most pleased with?"

A week to try

For the fridge: one small step a day

  • MonSwap "good job" for describing what you see 0 extra mins
  • TueNature documentary: narrate each other kindly 10 mins
  • WedAsk "tell me about this bit" 0 extra mins
  • ThuFive kind, true words for five people 15 mins
  • FriCatch yourself being brilliant 10 mins
  • SatMake a picture from what's on the ground, and talk about how 30 mins
  • SunAsk: which part are you most pleased with? 10 mins
One small thing each day, the same gentle rhythm the Wundoria app uses for its daily doors.
Start this week in the app

We will put each day on your family calendar, starting today, with the matching mission ready to open.

Questions parents ask

Is it bad to tell my child "good job"?

No. Warmth matters far more than perfect wording, and a cheerful "good job" now and then does no harm. The trouble comes when it's the only thing we say. Try mixing in moments where you describe what you see or ask about their work. Children feel more seen, and start to judge their own efforts rather than waiting for yours.

Should I praise effort or results?

Mostly effort, choices and strategies, because those are things a child can control and repeat. "You kept trying" helps a child face the next hard thing. Praising results or talent ("you're so clever") can make children cautious about trying anything new. It's still fine to share their delight when something works. Just keep the effort in view.

Do sticker charts and rewards work for kids?

They can help for a short time with a specific, dull task, like getting dressed or brushing teeth. For things a child might enjoy for their own sake, such as reading, drawing or being kind, rewards can backfire by making the activity feel like a job. Use them lightly, for a short while, and let them fade as the habit settles.